How to restrict an SSH user to file transfers

This blog post explains how a user on a Unix server can be restricted to file transfers only over SSH. The restriction is implemented by specifying a login shell which imposes a whitelist of allowed commands (e.g. rsync, sftp-server, scp, mkdir), and Unix permissions are used to restrict which files can be read and/or written by these commands.

Implementation using a custom login shell

First install Python 2 (as /usr/bin/python), then create a custom login shell binary, and save it to e.g. /usr/local/bin/transfer_shell. The contents of /usr/local/bin/transfer_shell should be:

#! /usr/bin/python
# by pts@fazekas.hu at Wed Dec  6 15:46:18 CET 2017

"""Login shell in Python 2 for SSH service restricted to data copying.

Use normal Unix permissions to restrict what files can be accessed.

import os
import stat
import sys

if os.access(__file__, os.W_OK) or os.access(
    os.path.dirname(__file__), os.W_OK):
  sys.stderr.write('error: copy shell not safe\n')
if os.getenv('SSH_ORIGINAL_COMMAND', ''):
  sys.stderr.write('error: bad command= config\n')

#cmd = os.getenv('SSH_ORIGINAL_COMMAND', '').split()
#print >>sys.stderr, sys.argv
cs = (len(sys.argv) == 3 and sys.argv[1] == '-c' and sys.argv[2]) or ''
if cs == '/bin/sh .ssh/rc':
cmd = cs.split()
# cmd0 will be '' for interactive shells, thus it will be disallowed.
cmd0 = (cmd or ('',))[0]
#print >>sys.stderr, sorted(os.environ)
if cmd0 not in ('ls', 'pwd', 'id', 'cat', 'echo', 'cp', 'mv', 'rm',
                'mkdir', 'rmdir',
                'rsync', 'scp', '/usr/lib/openssh/sftp-server'):
  # In case of sftp, we can't write to stderr.
  sys.stderr.write('error: command not allowed: %s\n' % cmd0)
def is_scp_unsafe(cmd):
  has_tf = False
  for i in xrange(1, len(cmd) - 1):
    arg = cmd[i]
    if arg == '--' or not arg.startswith('-'):
    elif arg in ('-t', '-f'):  # Flags indicating remote operation.
      has_tf = True
    elif arg not in ('-v', '-r', '-p', '-d'):
      return True
  return not has_tf
if ((cmd0 == 'rsync' and (len(cmd) < 2 or cmd[1] != '--server')) or
    cmd0 == 'scp' and is_scp_unsafe(cmd)):
  # This is to disallow arbitrary command execution with rsync -e and
  # scp -S.
  sys.stderr.write('error: command-line not allowed: %s\n' % cs)
os.environ['PATH'] = '/bin:/usr/bin'
os.environ.pop('DISPLAY', '')  # Disable X11.
os.environ.pop('XDG_SESSION_COOKIE', '')
os.environ.pop('XAUTHORITY', '')
except OSError:
  sys.stderr.write('error: data dir not found\n')
  # This is insecure: os.execl('/bin/sh', 'sh', '-c', cmd)
  os.execvp(cmd0, cmd)
except OSError:
  sys.stderr.write('error: command not found: %s\n' % cmd0)

Run these commands as root (without the leading #) to set the permissions transfer_shell:

# chown root.root /usr/local/bin/transfer_shell
# chmod 755       /usr/local/bin/transfer_shell

To set up restrictions for a new user

  1. Create the Unix user if not already created.
  2. Set up Unix groups and permissions on the system so the user doesn't have access to more files than he should have.
  3. Optionally, set up SSH public keys in ~/.ssh/authorized_keys for the user. No need to specify command="..." or other restrictions in that line.
  4. To change the login shell of the user, run this command as root (substituting USER with the login name of the user): chsh -s /usr/local/bin/transfer_shell USER
  5. Create a symlink named data in the home directory of the user. It should point to the default directory for file transfers.
  6. It's strongly recommended that you make the home directory and its contents unwritable by the user. Example command (run it as root, substitute USER): chown root.root ~USER ~USER/.ssh ~USER/.ssh/authorized_keys

Alternatives considered

  • Using a restrictive login shell and setting Unix file permissions. (This is implemented above, and also in scponly and rssh/) The disadvantage is that by accident the Unix permissions may be set up incorrectly (i.e. they are too permissive), and the user has access to too many files. Another disadvantage is that the custom login shell implementation may be vulnerable or hard to audit (example exploits for running arbitrary commands with rsync and scp: https://www.exploit-db.com/exploits/24795/).
  • Using a restrictive command="..." in ~/.ssh/authorized_keys. This is insecure, because OpenSSH sshd still runs ~/.bashrc and ~/.ssh/rc as shell scripts, and a malicious user could upload their own version of these files, or trigger some command execution in /etc/bash.bashrc. Any of these could lead to the user being able to execute arbitrary shell commands, which we don't want for this user.
  • Running a restrictive, custom SSH server implementation on a different port (while OpenSSH sshd is still running on port 22). This comes with its own risk of possible security bugs, and needs to be upgraded regularly. Also it can be complex to understand and set up correctly.
  • See some more alternatives here: https://serverfault.com/questions/83856/allow-scp-but-not-actual-login-using-ssh.

No comments: